Sarah Coleman, mural artist extraordinaire creates a magical visual environment at Nevada Theatre in Nevada City

Sarah Coleman's outstanding mural in the Nevada City Theatre
Sarah Coleman, mural artist
Sarah Coleman's outstanding mural in the Nevada City Theatre
“Drop by Drop, A River is Formed” honors the Nisenan, Nevada City’s original inhabitants. Photo by Akim Aginsky

“I just started to think about what could I do that would make everyone happy,” Coleman said. “How do I make this something for everyone.”

The end result was a collection of murals blending the natural wonders of the area into a fantasy world of color splashed across ceilings and cascading down walls. A fantasy world locals would recognize as their own. “People are rock hounds,” she said. “So I made sure in the back corners to create crystal caves.”

Surprisingly, the interior walls of the 1865 Nevada Theatre were undecorated in 2021. It seems an artist’s brush had never touched them. “It was like a blank canvas,” said mural artist Sarah Coleman. However, cleaning up the dusty historic walls was just part of the greatest challenge of her career: creating murals on the walls and ceilings of one of the most historic theaters in the West.

Also in the back of the theater, Coleman said, is ode to the forest and streams with spawning salmon as a nod to the area’s local history. This area is especially dedicated to the original Indiginous tribe of Nevada City: the Nisenan.  

This all took a lot of historical research on Coleman’s part before she could even imagine what murals to create.

And when a mural artist is painting not just one mural, but the entire inside of a theater, Coleman had to also respect the actors’ perspective from the stage.

She said she kept the designs balanced on opposing walls and gave a “center” to the back wall behind the stage. 

Some examples of Sarah Coleman’s many Nevada County murals. Photos by colemanpaintings.com

“To help them line up,: she said. “A certain part of the mural helps them see where they are.”

The idea for the project came from anonymous donors who love the theater building and also admired Coleman’s work. The donors chose her, but the Nevada Theatre’s Commission had final approval.

The Nevada Theatre was opened in 1865 where notables of the era, such as Mark Twain, stood on its stage. It is the oldest, continuously operated theater venue on the West Coast of the United States. The members of the commission would be sticklers about what art would be painted on such an historic edifice. It would also have to be an artist with extensive knowledge of painting murals and someone they could trust.

“They all knew what I could do,” Coleman said. “Thanks to the reputation I created they said to just go for it.”

After her sketches were approved, Coleman then discovered just how extensive the preparations would be before paint would even splash the walls. 

First she gathered helpers. Then the one ton of plaster smoothed the old walls. Two-story scaffolding reaching up 40 feet was erected. She ended up with three levels going up the sidewalls and one continuous floor suspended six feet below the ceiling.

Then a big surprise popped up when Coleman found the theater’s 100 seats would have to be removed, then reinstalled, by a specialty company in Los Angeles. This stretched out the deadline for completion even farther. However, the theater was already shuttered for a year due to Covid-19. This is where the pandemic provided a silver lining. “Luckily we saw that opening and just jumped on it,” she said.

Although Coleman was an experienced mural artist, she had never taken on a project of this magnitude.  “Being a project manager for something that scale was a new experience for me,” she said. “There was a huge learning curve.”

Sarah Coleman, paintbrush in hand, shown with her trusty "tool wagon" paints the scenic wall mural on the Target Building in Grass Valley, California
Sarah Coleman, famed Nevada City Theatre muralist working on the scenic wall at Target.

The art learning curve began for Coleman all the way back to elementary school where her teachers noticed her talent. She eventually earned a Bachelor of Fine Arts and a Bachelor of Cultural Anthropology from the University of California at Santa Cruz. From there she began painting seriously and selling work in galleries. But it wasn’t until she moved to Nevada City, she said, and found “her style” did her paintings become sought after.

“Most of the work sold” Coleman said, “and it was like a buzz started.”  Her paintings were selling across the country, then she began switching to large scale art in wall murals.

Close-up of Nevada Theatre mural
Nevada City Theatre’s mural close-up

“It takes the same amount of time as a small painting,” she said. “It’s just like you use bigger brushes.” 

She said the big difference is while creating a painting in her studio she could “dilly dally,” but with a mural she had deadlines to meet. 

In 2021 Coleman was now a veteran of the large wall mural. However the Nevada Theatre meant she was taking on the interior of an entire building. Luckily she had help from two other experienced muralists: Miles Toland and Brianna French.

“Together the three of us created a cohesive wonderland inside the auditorium that feels more than ever like a unique, moonlit chapel. Both artists brought so much talent and ideas to the table – I a.m. forever grateful. The project was incredibly smooth. Challenges included working in a dark space and creating a mural to be seen in very low light,” she writes on her website.

Since the project’s completion, Coleman has created other murals for the public to enjoy. However, the Nevada Theatre murals are renowned.

“The title is “Drop by Drop, A River is Formed”. This mural honors the Nisenan, Nevada City’s original inhabitants. It also celebrates the natural splendor we are so lucky to live in. My wish is for everyone who experiences this mural to feel inspired and at home.”